DONGJING MENG HUA LU / 卷十

駕詣郊壇行禮

The altar goes quiet.

The suburban sacrifice from the emperor’s tent to the burning furnace: a three-tier altar, an orchestra described instrument by instrument, three ascents alternating with a small tent, and a hush broken by a single command.

READ THE SACRIFICE ↓
TEXT-DERIVED ALTAR PLAN / GALOK READINGTwo tents and four named stairs, as the text gives them.

1. Three walls, two tents, one altar.

PRIMARY TEXT81A / WALLS / TENTS / THE ALTAR
三更,駕詣郊壇行禮。有三重壝墻。駕出青城,南行,曲尺西去約一里許,乃壇也。入外壝東門,至第二壝裏面南,設一大幕次,謂之「大次」。更換祭服:平天冠(二十四旒)、青袞龍服、中單、朱舄、純玉佩。二中貴扶侍,行至壇前。壇下又有一小幕殿,謂之「小次」,內有御座。臺高三層,七十二級,壇面方圓三丈許。有四踏道:正南曰午階,東曰卯階,西曰酉階,北曰子階。壇上設二黃褥位:北面南曰「昊天上帝」,東南面曰「太祖皇帝」。惟兩矮案上設禮料。有登歌道士十餘人,列鐘磬二架,餘歌色及琴瑟之類,三五執事人而已。
WORKING TRANSLATION

At the third watch the carriage went to the suburban altar to perform the rite. The altar has three concentric walls. The carriage left the Azure City and went south, then turned at a right angle to the west for about a li, and that was the altar. Entering by the east gate of the outer wall and reaching the inside of the second wall, facing south, a great curtained tent had been set up, called the “Great Tent.” There the emperor changed into sacrificial dress: the flat-heaven crown (with twenty-four pendants), the blue dragon robe, the inner garment, vermilion shoes, and pure-jade pendants. Two palace eunuchs supported him as he walked to the front of the altar. Below the altar there was a second, small curtained hall, called the “Small Tent,” with a throne inside. The terrace rises three tiers and seventy-two steps, and the altar surface measures some three zhang across. There are four stairways: due south is called the Noon stair, east the Mao stair, west the You stair, north the Zi stair. On the altar two yellow-cushioned places are laid out: the one on the north, facing south, is “August Heaven, Supreme Lord”; the one on the east, “southeast-facing,” is “Emperor Taizu.” There are only two low tables, on which the ritual materials are set. There are a dozen or more Daoists as singers of the ascending hymn, with two racks of bells and chimes; the rest of the singers, the zithers and the like amount to just three or five attendants.

GALOK READING

The unit moves the emperor through space before it shows him doing anything. A route (south, then a right-angle turn west, about a li), three walls, two tents, and a wardrobe list: the emperor is first visible as a sequence of garments. Then the altar is given by number, three tiers, seventy-two steps, three zhang, and by four stairs named with the cyclical branches 午 卯 酉 子, which also work as compass points. Two seats carry the whole theology: Heaven on the north facing south, Taizu on the east. The text prints that orientation as 東南面 and the page does not emend it. The setting is plain. Two low tables, a dozen Daoist singers, and only a few attendants; the text does not say why Daoists sing the ascending hymn. All the magnificence is reserved for the next unit.

2. The orchestra, piece by piece.

PRIMARY TEXT81B / PALACE-FRAME ENSEMBLE / INSTRUMENTS
壇前設宮架樂,前列編鐘、玉磬。其架有如常樂方響,增其高大。編鐘形稍褊,上下兩層掛之,架兩角綴以流蘇。玉磬狀如曲尺,繫其曲尖處,亦架之,上下兩層掛之。次列數架大鼓,或三或五,用木穿貫,立於架座上。又有大鐘曰景鐘,曰節鼓。有琴而長者,如箏而大者,截竹如簫管、兩頭存節而橫吹者,有土燒成如圓彈而開竅者,如笙而大者,如簫而增其管者。有歌者,其聲清亮,非鄭衛之比。
WORKING TRANSLATION

In front of the altar a palace-frame orchestra is set up. In front are ranged the tuned bells and the jade chimes. The racks are like those of the ordinary fangxiang (the metal-plate frame) but made taller and larger. The bells are slightly flattened in shape and hung in an upper and lower tier, the two corners of the rack hung with tassels. The jade chimes are shaped like a carpenter’s square, hung from the point of the bend, and likewise racked in upper and lower tiers. Next are ranged several racks of great drums, three or five, with a wooden shaft threaded through each and standing upright on the rack base. There are also great bells called the “Jing bell” and the “Jie drum.” There are zithers, long ones; instruments like a zheng but larger; bamboo cut like a xiao pipe with a node left at both ends and blown across; instruments of fired clay shaped like a round pellet with openings pierced in it; some like a sheng but larger; and some like a xiao but with extra pipes. There are singers, whose voices are clear and bright, not to be compared with the music of Zheng and Wei.

GALOK READING

Meng describes ritual instruments the way a visitor describes unfamiliar objects: by comparison with the music his readers know. The racks are “like ordinary fangxiang, but taller”; the winds are “like a zheng but larger,” “like a sheng but larger,” “like a xiao with more pipes.” Later readers match the clay pellet with openings and the cross-blown bamboo with named ritual instruments, but the text names none of them. Nothing is said of pitch, tunes or hymn titles, so the passage is material and visual: tiers, tassels, a carpenter’s-square shape, shafts through drums. The single judgment is moral and aesthetic at once. The voices are clear and bright, and “not comparable to Zheng and Wei,” the old names for licentious music. The orchestra has to be heard as the opposite of entertainment.

3. Dancers, bells and the box that opens the music.

PRIMARY TEXT81C / MUSICIANS / DANCERS / ZHU AND YU
宮架前立兩竿,樂工皆裹介幘(如籠巾),緋寬衫,勒帛。二舞者頂紫色冠,上有橫板,皂服,朱裙,履。樂作,初則文舞,皆手執一紫囊,盛一笛管,結帶。武舞,一手執短矟,一手執小牌。比文舞加數人,擊銅鐃、響環,又擊如銅竈突者;又兩人共攜一銅甕,就地擊者。舞者如擊刺,如乘雲,如分手,皆舞容矣。樂作,先擊柷(以木為之,如方壺,畫山水之狀),每奏樂,擊之內外,共九下。樂止,則擊敔(如伏虎,脊上如鋸齒),一曲終,以破竹刮之。
WORKING TRANSLATION

In front of the palace frame stand two poles. The musicians all wear a jie headcloth (like a basket-shaped cap), scarlet wide-sleeved shirts and silk sashes. The performers of the two dances wear purple caps with a cross-board on top, black clothes, vermilion skirts, and shoes. When the music begins, the civil dance comes first: each dancer holds a purple bag containing a flute-pipe, tied with a cord. In the martial dance each holds a short spear in one hand and a small shield in the other. Compared with the civil dance, several more people are added, who strike bronze cymbals and ringing hoops, and also strike something shaped like a bronze stove-flue; and two men together carry a bronze jar and strike it on the ground. The dancers move as if striking and stabbing, as if riding clouds, as if parting hands — all of it is dance posture. At the start of the music the zhu is struck first (made of wood, like a square jar, painted with a landscape); each time music is played it is struck, inside and out, nine blows in all. When the music stops, the yu is struck (like a crouching tiger with a saw-toothed ridge along its back), and at the end of a piece it is scraped with split bamboo.

GALOK READING

Meng gives costume, prop and gesture, never melody. The civil dancers hold a purple bag with a flute-pipe in it; the martial dancers hold a short spear and a small shield; the added percussion includes a bronze jar struck on the ground by two men sharing the carry. Three dance gestures, striking and stabbing, riding clouds, parting hands, are reported as what the dance “looks like,” which is how an onlooker reports it. The two framing instruments are described by shape. The zhu is a box painted with a landscape, struck nine times at the start. The yu is a crouching tiger whose serrated back is scraped with split bamboo to end a piece. Beginning and ending are marked by objects with animal and scenic surfaces, and the unit gives both operations, beginning and end, in exact counts and actions.

4. Three ascents, and the offerants in between.

PRIMARY TEXT81D / ASCENTS / OFFERINGS / THE TEXT READ
禮直官奏請駕登壇,前導官皆躬身側引。至壇止,惟大禮使登之。先正北一位,拜跪酒,殿中監東向一拜,進爵盞,再拜,興。復詣正東一位,纔登壇而宮架聲止,則壇上樂作;降壇,則宮架樂復作,武舞上。復歸小次。亞獻、終獻上,亦如前儀,當時燕越王為亞、終獻也。第二次登壇,樂作如初,跪酒畢,中書舍人讀冊,左右兩人舉冊而跪讀。降壇,復歸小次,亞、終獻如前。再登壇,進玉爵盞,皇帝飲福矣。亞、終獻畢,降壇,駕小次前立,則壇上禮料、幣帛、玉冊由酉階而下。
WORKING TRANSLATION

The ritual usher memorializes, requesting the emperor to ascend the altar; the officials who guide him in front all bend at the waist and lead him from the side. At the altar they stop; only the Grand Ceremonies Commissioner ascends with him. First, at the northernmost place, he bows and kneels to offer wine; the Palace Director, facing east, bows once and presents the cup; the emperor bows twice and rises. Then he goes to the place due east. As soon as he has ascended the altar, the palace-frame music stops and the music on the altar begins; when he descends, the palace-frame music resumes and the martial dancers come up. He returns to the Small Tent. The Second and Final Offerants ascend, also following the earlier procedure (at that time the Princes of Yan and Yue served as Second and Final Offerants). On the second ascent the music plays as at first; when the kneeling libation is finished, the Secretariat Drafter reads the text, two men on the left and right holding the document up while he reads kneeling. He descends and returns to the Small Tent; the Second and Final Offerants proceed as before. On the next ascent the jade cup is presented, and the emperor drinks the blessing wine. When the Second and Final Offerants have finished, he descends and stands before the Small Tent, and the ritual materials, silks and the jade text on the altar go down by the west stair.

GALOK READING

The logic of the unit is alternation. Each time the emperor climbs, the orchestra at the foot of the altar falls silent and the small ensemble on the altar plays; each time he descends, the order is reversed and the martial dancers come up. Between ascents he goes back to the Small Tent, and the offerants take his place. Only one official climbs with him, so the top of a three-tier altar holds very few people. Offices are named but never explained: Ritual Usher, Grand Ceremonies Commissioner, Palace Director, Secretariat Drafter. What the sacrifice says is almost entirely absent. The text is “read,” but its words are not given; the reader sees two men holding the document up while a third kneels to read. The one sign of memory in the unit is the aside about the Princes of Yan and Yue, “at that time,” which marks the account as drawn from a particular occasion that the entry leaves unnamed.

5. The furnace, the stars and a hush.

PRIMARY TEXT81E / BURNING / THE TWELVE NICHES / THE LAST BOW
南壝門外,去壇百餘步,有燎爐,高丈許。諸物上臺,一人點唱,入爐焚之。壇三層,回踏道之間有十二龕,祭十二宮神;內壝外祭百星。執事與陪祠官,皆面北立班。宮架樂罷,鼓吹未作,外內數十萬眾,肅然惟聞輕風環佩之聲。一贊者喝曰:「贊一拜!」皆拜,禮畢。
WORKING TRANSLATION

Outside the south gate of the wall, a hundred-odd paces from the altar, there is a burning furnace about a zhang high. The various materials are raised onto the platform, one man calls them off by name, and they are put into the furnace and burned. Around the three tiers of the altar, between the stairways, there are twelve niches, where sacrifice is made to the gods of the twelve houses; outside the inner wall the hundred stars are sacrificed to. The attendants and the assisting sacrificial officials all stand in ranks facing north. When the palace-frame music has ended and the drums and winds have not yet begun, the hundreds of thousands inside and outside are hushed, and one hears only the light wind and the sound of jade pendants. One announcer shouts, “Announce: one bow!” and all bow. The rite is complete.

GALOK READING

The offerings leave the altar by the west stair and end in a furnace outside the gate, where one man calls out each item as it goes in. The spirits are laid out as space: twelve niches between the stairways, the hundred stars outside the inner wall. The climax then comes as silence rather than as music. The orchestra has stopped, the drums have not begun, and the only sounds Meng reports are wind and jade pendants. The crowd figure, 數十萬, is not a head count and should not be treated as one; it is a gesture at a hush that included everyone. The last command is the shortest line in the entry, “one bow,” and the account ends there, with the whole assembly bowing and no word about the emperor himself. The next entry begins with him leaving the altar.

06 / TEXT DETECTIVE

The longest passage, and three things to watch.

禮直官…由酉階而下COLLATION / PASSAGE ONLY IN SIKU

The stretch from 禮直官 to 由酉階而下, with the three ascents and the Princes of Yan and Yue, is in the Siku witness but missing from the modern punctuated edition consulted for punctuation. The page keeps it. In the same edition 南壝門外 appears as 門外.

亞獻、終獻上READING / PUNCTUATION

The line 亞獻終獻上亦如前儀 can be read with 上 as “ascend” or as “the emperor.” Given the emperor’s return to the Small Tent and the later 亞、終獻如前, the page reads 上 as “ascend.” It is a reading, not a collation result.

臺高三層 · 東南面 · 內壝外COLLATION / ORIENTATION

Siku reads 臺高三層 where a modern edition has 壇高三層. The seat of Taizu is printed 東南面 and kept as printed. Siku reads 內壝外祭百星 where a modern edition has 內外祭百星. The page follows Siku in all three places.

大次 · 小次GREAT TENT / SMALL TENT

Two curtained shelters: the large one in the second enclosure for robing, and a smaller hall below the altar with a throne.

午 卯 酉 子THE FOUR STAIRS

Cyclical branches that also stand for south, east, west and north; the text names them as stair labels.

宮架PALACE-FRAME ENSEMBLE

The large ensemble of suspended bells and chimes, drums and winds set up in front of the altar for the rite.

柷 · 敔ZHU AND YU

The wooden box struck to begin a piece and the tiger-shaped scraper struck and scraped to end it, as the text describes them.

亞獻 · 終獻SECOND / FINAL OFFERANT

The two further offerants who follow the emperor’s first offering; here, the Princes of Yan and Yue.

燎爐BURNING FURNACE

The furnace outside the south gate where silks, jade text and materials were called out and burned.

03 / A RITE IN PLACESThe rite is told by where everyone stands.

Entry 81 offers an altar by number, an orchestra by comparison, a sequence by alternation of music, and a climax by silence. The words of the sacrifice are never given. What the text preserves is position: who may climb, who kneels to read, where the furnace stands, which way the officials face. The next entry takes the emperor down from the altar and lets the noise return.

外內數十萬眾,肅然惟聞輕風環佩之聲。
07 / SOURCE TRAIL

The positions are Meng’s. The punctuation is editorial.

The primary text is read from the Siku-family witness (Kanripo KR2k0111, 卷十); punctuation and the standardization of Siku variant glyphs are editorial. The passage 禮直官…由酉階而下 is read from the Siku scan alone; see Text Detective.